Sunday, 4 August 2013

“Is your mother a Member of Parliament?”

Foreword: This piece is a salute to the best of systems in my country which continue to render their best despite a million constraints and obstacles;  and do so with the dignity of an indefatigable spirit.

“Is your mother a Member of Parliament?”

I was quite taken aback by the rather innocuous inquiry at the Central Government Health Scheme (CGHS) counter at the Nizams Institute of Medical Sciences (NIMS) in Hyderabad. The person who asked the question was the rather affable and endearing clerk, processing the admission of my mother into the private ward of the hospital for a major surgery for stomach cancer.

“Why do you ask?” I said.
“This is the most expensive ward, occupied only by VIPs”, he said.

It was then that I realized: my late father, who was a man of very humble means till his last breath, (his father incidentally was a doctor, an FRCS from London who served the last Nizam of Hyderabad), did attain a significant position in his government job; which entitled his surviving spouse to avail the facility of a decent room and world class treatment in a government hospital. 

A five star cancer hospital which my mother chose at first for its great ambiance and infrastructure (which had generated great confidence in her), hesitated to operate upon her due to the high risks involved in the surgery (read it as …. possible absence of a wide variety of experts in house, to treat complicated cases). However, the surgeons of the government hospital exhibited great confidence and sagacity in planning the surgery; considering carefully, all the risks involved. 

A month long association with the NIMS and watching the things around me; I write this piece even as my mother is in the Surgical Intensive Care Unit (which looks like a dingy rickety medical facility from medieval times). One even wonders, if anybody has ever emerged alive from it. The pre- operation surgical ward would have even the bravest, running away from the surgery at the last minute… But if the facility is good enough for my countrymen who flock to the hospital in large numbers… then definitely it should be good enough for me or my mother or even a VIP or even the Prime Minister of the country.

One might wonder what is the point I am driving at and who has compelled me to get my mother treated at the hospital whose facilities seem so bleak and moreover,

 What does culture have to do with this saga?

I went to NIMS; only for advice from the surgical oncology and surgical gastroenterology departments, which was mandatory; so that my mother could avail the government funding to get treated at a hospital of her choice (a five star facility near my home). 

I waited in the endless Qs of the sea of humanity at NIMS to meet the doctors in their ramshackle office (Some of their departments are now housed in brand new state of art buildings with plush interiors, but not the surgical gastroenterology department and the operation theaters.)

At the first meeting with the doctors I could not help but feel- Why can they not smile a tad more to make the patient comfortable? ( I have got used to an overdose of hospitality and PR skills travelling round the country as the representative of  a premier journal on dance, Nartanam and also having exposure to the  PR and HRD functions of the corporate sector by virtue of my education in Business Management.) 

But, here are the reasons why my mother and I chose the government facility over any other:

The tehzeeb of the doctors came through in the calm and yet the reassuring way they talked, minus any attitude and show off....

The senior most anesthetist, whom the surgeons wanted to handle my mother’s complicated case, looked positively unapproachable and his menacing steady gaze at the first sight did not seem very warm; and I could not but help wish again that the doctors smiled more often to let the patient know that the doctor is not a monster whom you have to bear with, to get treated. Is medicine with its human element and compassion not a subtle art in itself with its own aesthetic?

However, the calm and composed mannerism of the senior most anesthetist, as I observed him a couple of times more, had me wanting to believe in him. I could even appreciate the cultured personage behind a tad too spartan facade. I developed immense faith in him and in the affable head of the department of surgical gastroenterology and his able team - not just because of their professional credentials- but because of the stated elegance in their very presence.... which was  not misplaced; the way my mother's surgery was accomplished.

In arts, especially in dance, this very quality of calm or tranquility which translates into elegance as the dancer displays his/her skill is called Thehraav; which comes from the self assurance emerging from intensive training in the art form and a deep understanding of nature, culture and ones own SELF.

The huge NIMS  runs quite efficiently with the support staff working like cogs in a wheel catering to large volumes of the sick who are also poor. 

But yes, enhancing the infrastructure and attempting to provide a more humane touch by training the support staff to be a little courteous (Maybe just a smile and a gentle tone of speech would do) would multiply the capable doctors’ magnificent efforts. Having said that, I wonder if hospitals are not considered a hospitality sector?

Culture is definitely an essential ingredient of all professions. 
I certainly have discovered that culture is very much a part of the doctors I have come across at NIMS. Moreover, the manifestation of culture in a person need not always be on overt display or be loud or voluminous or stylish in words or deeds; culture could rest in the smallest of ones mannerisms.

And if the Director of NIMS cares for the feed back of an ordinary citizen; he could arrange for the training of the support staff to be courteous and efficient;
and do well to immediately get better infrastructure to do justice to the efforts of the world class doctors working at the institute.

HRD (Human Resource Development) in corporate style is not what I am hinting at! 

May be a deep conversation with the sterling arts-  especially music, dance, literature and the like- right from ones early growing years is the only way to enrich a person with exalted human values. 


On a lighter note, maybe NIMS should begin by immediately replacing the table seen below:
Note the ingeniously bandaged legs of the table- to keep it from collapsing.

Thursday, 18 July 2013

Deconstructing SELF WORTH


I want fame and power... money may follow
or
I want money... fame and power may follow.

I am not suggesting that quest for above is unethical in any way. 

I want to look beyond the self righteous, rational, and conscious mind of mine to know what actually motivates me at my work; and if there is a cut throat subconscious rationale which actually works stronger and guides my work. 

Whatever be the quality of my work and my contribution to the world at large, does not the above mantra  play a defining role in what I do and how I do it? Einstein, Edison, Shakespeare, Beethoven or Van Gogh- all who attained fame or success in their lifetime or after; what did they aspire for?

A love and commitment for what they were doing and a burning desire to satisfy their artistic or scientific quest seems to have lead to their contribution becoming so immense that they have been immortalized. If they had any faculties of financial acumen and if they had designed the graph of their success consciously, is a matter that I do not know of.

I know for sure that today, the need to be recognized and to wield influence (by being written about; by being seen in peer communities, on social medium and social circuits; by being on committees that matter in terms of prestige or which offer one the satisfaction of being considered as eminent and also offer the power to trade favors; or by being honored and awarded- no matter what the award or honor is), is quite pressing.

I cannot leave the matter of being influential to follow the excellence in my work but instead I have to work consciously towards attaining the desired position of influence.

Fame or recognition seems to invest me with a high sense of self worth. 
I justify aspiring for it; but I wonder why does not a good body of ones work, by itself, lead to the self worth, nullifying the need for recognition. A peer review or appraisal and approval is more important to evaluate and correct my work but not to enhance my self worth.


I shall not probe any further.... for I might discover my true intentions/ motivations... and the pious garb may unveil my reality....

Saturday, 15 June 2013

Maybe, we now need HR Consultants in Arts.

Last week I was with the founder publisher of Nartanam, who in recouping from a bad bout of spondylitis was glad that I dropped by to have lunch with him and thereafter spend time to visit the vibrant Kuchipudi scenario from his past. Despite a killing schedule of mine I could not take leave of him as he went down the memory lane of his association with Vempati Chinna Satyam. As was always the case, I ended up handing him tissues to wipe the streaming tears of affection and reverence for the great Master.

Watching the video recordings from the 80s and 90s of the Kuchipudi Mahotsavas conducted by the Kuchipudi Kala Kendra which brought together the entire Kuchipudi fraternity, brought many things to the mind.

G M Sarma, founder of  the once vibrant Kuchipudi Kala Kendra, Mumbai and the former publisher of Nartanam is past the prime of his robust organizing days. At the simplest, he can be termed as a Kuchipudi connoisseur minus any personal agenda; who did his selfless best for the propagation of Kuchipudi and retired gracefully.

Quite in contrast are today’s many managers/organizers of arts festivals who revel in the bloated perception of being the “karta dharta’ of arts and the artists. Especially the “want to be’s” have no option but to pander to the egos of these entities who wield considerable influence. 
               
As one watched the videos of the great maestro Vempati performing, one could not help but realize that here was a maestro who was capable of being a star performer himself. Flawless “saushtava” (the perfect body posture, line), the charming gait, the perfected ease of technique, the magnetic presence on stage; he was no doubt a scintillating performer material.

But he went on to attain fame as an excellent teacher and choreographer whose pantheon of stellar disciples is truly vast. An excellent leader and team player, his revolutionized Kuchipudi in a way only he could have. The best of writers, music composers, musicians, singers, make-up artists, his teaching assistants, patrons and disciples- all rallied around him and he held them with the awe that his art inspired in them. And thus, was created the best of art. None from the team sought individual stardom; they all rallied around the maestro to create his master pieces. They were happy with his art and the immense fame it garnered for him. Would terming them as “selfless” be too big a credit accorded to the team members who were not mere mortals in their own right.

Apart from the leadership that the Master and his art inspired, it was the lack of craving for individual fame and stardom which makes those team members unique. It is another matter that every one of the team members today is a legend in his/her own right- S. V. Bhujangaraya Sarma, an eloquent poet,           P. Sangeetha Rao, a fabulous musician, Parthan, the set designer, Kanaka Durga, the ethereal singer, Bala Kondala Rao, Master’s right hand in teaching and choreographing, his star dancers, whose list is endless; and I shall not even make an attempt to list them….

I cannot but draw comparison here to Sergei Diaghilev, the Russian impresario who revolutionized Ballet by the sheer magnificence of the team that he built. Every member was a gem of an artist who worked towards the team goal of  creating a flawless artistic product.

Recently, talking to Vedantam Venkatachalapati Rao, one of the most talented youngsters of Kuchipudi and reminiscing about his equally talented elder brother Vedantam Raghava, a dancer par excellence, especially in playing the flamboyant roles in the Kuchipudi Yakshaganas, who now lives in the USA; I could not help but complain that- not one such leader as Vempati Chinna Satyam has emerged in this generation while, individually, there are many talented dancers and teachers, who may attain fame. But none, I am sure, will be hailed for generations to come.

To even fathom, how on this God’s big complex earth was such a team put together by Guru Vempati Chinna Satyam, could be a great challenge for the best of the Human Resource Consultants.

Maybe, now Art will need Human Resource Consultants- to put together teams which will create great art.


Wednesday, 15 May 2013

Not a part of SPIC MACAY




To write my blog I am usually looking out for pleasant and inspiring happenings in day to day life which enable my pen to write in enthusiasm. But it is also interesting and at times amusing to observe the other side of human nature… cunning, aggression and mistrust which drains all energies and takes one away from productive work…

Not long ago I wrote a piece about Dr Kiran Seth and how an entire movement was spearheaded to a dizzy success just because the man is the bearer of an honest simplicity. Of course he could not have done it without the sterling volunteers who make his mission possible. My writing was from my first hand interaction with Kiran Seth and his gems of volunteers. 

In fact, my young daughter who read the post, “How does one figure out Kiran Seth” commented, “Ma, you have created a new God, adding one more to the already huge pantheon of Gods in India.”

All I could tell her was, you have to meet him to believe me.

Today I am inspired to write how a couple of other volunteers of the movement have amused me, frightened me, and have compelled me to reflect-  if aggression could ever be a justified means of attaining a goal, however worthy it might be.

A very small job of editing a souvenir for the 1st international convention of SPIC MACAY at IIM-C, Kolkata, gave me a first hand experience of chaos in communication, unclear duties and responsibilities, non cooperation, disrespect for a fellow human being, especially in mails, ego hassles and above all a rare cunning which  did not appear constructive.

I seek forgiveness if I sound judgemental, but I share this post as an exercise in reflecting how I can rise above petty human emotions to make my life better and thus make the world a better place to live in.

When I was bogged down, not knowing how to accomplish my work in a chaotic situation I was confronted with, I gave up and eased myself out of the project. But within no time I was again sought by the organizers to take up the task of creating the Souvenir. 

And much against commonsense, I put aside an important order which I had to execute to earn the much needed money for my journal on classical dances of India, Nartanam. Since the Souvenir had to be executed at the last minute, I had no other option but to utilize the designer and printing slots allotted for Nartanam at my regular press, delaying my own project . It is important to point out that the Souvenir was delayed by the trademark lack of clarity and mis- communication and even excessive communication in SPIC MACAY even though the content was ready. All the top writers whom I had sought were utmost professional and had sent in their beautiful pieces well before the deadline. Wasting precious human resource by doubling the work; and confusion with too many cooks spoiling the broth is another syndrome which was difficult to handle.

It is another matter that no one reads on classical arts any more; not realizing that the sastra or the theory is as important for an artist and a spectator as the actual performance is.

A couple of volunteers whom I sought help from did all that they could without batting an eyelid while some others were creating agony and confusion.  

One of the volunteers who lives in my city, whom I was not acquainted with earlier, was of great help. His excellent attitude and quick thinking ability was an asset. A meticulous worker with sharp skills, he was an editor’s delight. With his help, the entire souvenir took shape against many odds and has now gone for print; and hopefully it will reach Kolkata in time for the inauguration of the Convention.

Happy that the souvenir has been put to bed I left the press; and before getting on with my other pressing engagements checked my mail as a routine; and to my amusement, I find a mail that this volunteer (who was an asset with his attitude and skills and gave all help to a stranger like me and did all the menial jobs assigned to him, if at all any job can be called so....) is declared as not belonging to the city SPIC MACAY by the group leader due to some serious issues with him.

Can a volunteer be banished for a little or a great fault, if any at all? who decides who is at fault? Whatever be the reason, can cultural ambassadors be intolerant and unprofessional and thus aggressive?

As Bertrand Russell puts it- the vagaries of human nature!

It might take a lot of culture to overcome these vagaries!

Monday, 15 April 2013

A Judgement


Today’s blog comes from a friend’s verdict on me yesterday after a minor/maybe a major altercation with him over a trivial personal issue but unfortunately placed at  a time of the turbulent milieu of my high passion and severe frustration of running a classical dance journal Nartanam. A journal which is highly respected in dance and academic circles, but costs a handsome packet of money in publishing it every quarter of an year; which many want it almost free of cost or complementary. Paying for a subscription of thousand Indian rupees per annum is a terrible expense (discounted price is Rs 750 only, which one spends in one evening watching a movie…); that is not the issue under discussion…. It is that no dancer or dance student has the time to read. Reading on dance by a dancer (though sastra is an integral part of learning and viewing dance) is only when a newspaper carries a review of her/his performance or when Nartanam publishes an article with a picture of the dancer. Many have expressed that if dance is presented in the format of a film news magazine, maybe they would be interested in reading.



Back and Front page of the latest issue of Nartanam- A special on the great Kutiyattam exponent
Late Guru Mani Madhava Chakyar


 Coming back to the verdict of my dear friend; it was, “You have no sense of decorum. You have been really damaged by your past with many complexes….Therefore all your Yoga has not helped you.”

Indeed it has set me thinking.... if I am unable to maintain dignity and decorum in my day to day life and in my efforts to pursue my love; then it is no love at all… especially the love of classical arts…. 

One does not make public, one's troubled past which many of us have in one way or the other locked away…. barring a few who by virtue of a silver spoon of high birth or fortune may never have had a trouble in their entire lives. To be fair to the people in my life …. I shall maintain the anonymity of the alcoholic who is supposed to have damaged my past and induced in me, many complexes…. But I will not shy away from mentioning that I was indeed a severely battered family member of an alcoholic. An alcoholic who is now recovering and who has had the grace and dignity of setting a beautiful example of what grit and strength is, what forgiveness is all about. He has not only built back his own battered life but has assumed all his worldly responsibilities towards everyone he is related to… and even towards people he is not related to.

....and above all, ironically, this recovering alcoholic gives me the assurance when the going gets tough financially at the journal, that he is there to pick up the bills of Nartanam and actually does so every time I run short of funds.

I have often wondered why I do the work I do, write and publish a serious academic journal on Indian dance.  Having spent my youth juggling with the tough deal of cards that life dealt me; ending up completely wrecked and exhausted; where living every new day was an ordeal and was infested with great uncertainty… Did I get suddenly ambitious of becoming a culture vulture and thus schemed and designed my life to become a writer, teacher and publisher of a dance journal, a career which does not pay in India. No, I did not…. I just went about doing what circumstances had led me to, followed my passion and what I believed in.

Now I come to another part of my friend’s verdict …. Sahaja Yoga, a form of meditation. Practicing it gave me immense peace and serenity during my troubled times. It gave me the grace and dignity to deal with things, gave me the qualities of forgiveness, satisfaction, innocence, true seeking of knowledge, a diplomacy and sweetness of voice and approach and above all a sense of self realization. But yoga was soon forgotten as better times arrived and my  focus shifted from my miseries to the “Moha maya” of life and pursuits of worldly love and goals….

Nartanam is one such goal… what if we bring out a world class journal on classical arts? What if it is in a small way, an effort to preserve and propagate our culture? What if it requires the toil and labor demanding sweat and blood? What if it does not pay the writers and the people running it even for their bread? Generating the finances to run it without compromising on the quality of the content is in itself a huge task…. 

And the irony is that a recovering alcoholic… who was no better than the scum of the earth, not long ago, is its patron… He does not believe in supporting a non self sustaining venture…. but has the compassion and the hope  that the journal ought to be given a decent chance to survive…. especially after being taken over in a financially sick condition from the former publisher….

Many luminaries and successful people who are on the board of advisers of Nartanam are rendering their moral support by lending graciously their eminent and renowned names to the journal… there are writers (though very few) who send in excellent writings with no expectation of financial remuneration….God has been benevolent…. Somehow money comes to pay the printers and the writers. Then what is it that bothers me, troubles me, and leads me to behave in frustration while dealing with personal and professional issues, to warrant the comment…

“You have no sense of decorum. You have been really damaged by your past with many complexes….Therefore all your Yoga has not helped you.”

I do not know! But I want to figure out... as anything worth doing ought to be done with grace and dignity… or else it is better not done…there is no place for frustration and palming off my behavior to some relevant/irrelevant factor…. Sahaja Yoga was not to be used as a  mantra for negotiating problems … it was meant  to be a way of life… Her Holiness Shri Mataji  (Dr. Nirmala Srivastava) left behind a simple form of meditation which  has now been thoroughly subjected to scientific exploration  by eminent institutions for holistic health and it has been researched for its impact on aesthetics of a beautiful life and of arts. 

I have written an elaborate book on the spirituality, divinity, aesthetics and spectatorship of classical performing arts and have discovered a theory from a medieval treatise on dance which expounds a mechanism which has been coincidentally, adequately clarified and researched in Sahaja Yoga and the medical fraternity…. And I wanted to publish this book.  Please believe me, I do not have any religious prejudices and my approach to the above mentioned work was purely academic and scientific…

But after my friend’s judgement…. which, after the initial emotional outburst, I am examining clinically…Maybe,  I am neither a worthy author for expounding such profound beauty of classical arts and its theories; maybe I am not worthy of an exalted form of meditation like Sahaja Yoga, and further, maybe, I am not even a worthy editor of a much worthy journal which deals with divinity… with arts... with dance.

I can pray to the almighty to help me in my efforts to spiritually uplift myself which might reflect in every aspect of my personality in ordinary and extra ordinary circumstances of stress, in times of these worldly affairs and passions… .

If only, every person who values his country/ culture/ arts made an attempt to buy and read Nartanam which costs peanuts… I do not have to run from pillar to post seeking donations, advertisements and patronage and grants from government bodies and corporates alike…. 

Readership is the only patronage which can run Nartanam…. We, the people, shall contribute to keep our culture alive…. And then, any amount of toil, failures and frustrations would be worth it.

Strange is my post today which mixes up my personal passions, failings and a larger interest of a non profit venture. My miserable past, I cannot erase…. and will have to deal with the complexes arising from it... and hopefully somewhere I would attain the decorum to carry on with conviction in my beliefs without succumbing to stress and failures.

Monday, 8 April 2013

How does one figure out Kiran Seth?


Before I come to the protagonist of today’s blog I need to mention that I have always, ever since my childhood, wondered what “selflessness” was about? What was meant by the slogan, “Let go let God”? What was “detachment”? What was “forgiveness”? What was “nishkaam karma”? The pious quotes from Bhagwad Gita were a steady drone in the ears during growing up years.

Yes, people around me did possess one or the other exalted qualities mentioned above but to me they failed invariably in some sterling quality or the other. My young mind during growing up years registered that those were the exalted goals which were meant to be preached but do not exist in reality. Only saints are blessed with those qualities and ordinary people cannot be saints. 

Into this milieu of my impressionable mind entered education, success, power, career, cut throat competition and the women’s empowerment, etc.  The last term especially caused a lot of agony personally because I did not understand what it was about… in our homes the women always wielded a lot of influence and commanded respect… they were empowered even if they did not go out for building careers outside home…. The man of the house entrusted the woman with his entire earnings and thus she was financially empowered too! Women in our families were home makers and they did a damn good job of it…. They were like the women characters in our epics that fascinated me for their strength and resilience.

Yes, there is a lot of exploitation and atrocity against women out in the world which one ought to fight back against and thus assert oneself… and I air my voice for them… but I could never see Sita, Draupadi or any other character from the epics as a wronged or a weak woman....

Then entered into my intellect the dimension of reality vs ideology when as an adult I set out to live my life…. as a home maker....I had the fortune of being in constant touch with classical dance and music and other arts which helped me grow… the seeds of which were sown with zeal by my ORDINARY father in his children’s upbringing….

After having mapped my intellectual and emotional inclinations and where they emerge from…..

Let me come back to the protagonist of today’s blog, Kiran Seth, the founder of SPIC MACAY (The Society for the Promotion of Indian Classical Music And Culture Amongst Youth) which in the past 3 decades has made a tremendous difference to the country’s youth (how tangible or intangible; is a matter of study in itself) by taking classical music and culture to school children across the country and abroad and making an indelible impact on their young souls. No mean job.

Everyone agrees that our arts are the richest and most enriching as a necessary input to character building which invests one with all possible wisdom; but somehow they always take a back seat in day to day lives.

Set out to study SPIC MACAY as a part of my Senior Research fellowship I came in contact with Kiran Seth and many of the sterling volunteers of SPIC MACAY. A loosely knit structure SPIC MACAY is an example of a baffling movement which no structured government body can ever dream to emulate in propagating classical arts and culture. I will not deal with the finer details of the movement, its operations and its impact here. 

In this post I just want to figure out the persona that Kiran Seth is. Every volunteer whom I had met and interviewed spoke of him in a superlative adulatory tone. Some of them are his hardest critics with respect to his managerial and financial acumen and vociferously point out the flaws in the execution of his ideology, lack of strategy, planning, etc. However their bitter criticism always ends with an emphatic BUT…. He is the driving force of the movement!

Being allergic to hero worship, it was hard for me to take their assessment at face value. However always wary of any researcher’s bias, I went about observing him and talking to him for quite some time now and here is what I have arrived at… A simple summary of him with no IFs and BUTs…

This man is as simple as one can get nearest to the term SIMPLE… He is a very ORDINARY person who MERELY lives the properties of selflessness, detachment and nishkaam karm, does his work without any expectation what so ever. He is driven by single minded devotion to the cause he believes in and owns a super positive outlook with no trappings to distract him. He simply believes in the strengths of the people and places indomitable faith in them and brushes off their weaknesses as inconsequential. A generous dose of humility is a mere extension of his personality.

The only area he does not compromise in is the artistic excellence and brilliance of the artists and their art which is taken by the SPIC MACAY to the youth to enable them to experience a life transforming beauty and doing so with grace and dignity.

He is a leader who has assembled a network of people who are smarter than him in many ways and is an excellent team member and follower in the team which he has put together and inspires.

I think one really cannot figure out Kiran Seth in terms of the words in a lexicon as all analysis leads to the word – SAINT.

I definitely am not a believer in Hero worship! In fact I am allergic to eulogizing a mere man….BUT….

Thursday, 7 March 2013

The Mal Nourished Soul



I switch on the Television only to come across a feature which proclaims that the capital of India ranks first in mal nourishment of children followed by Bihar and Odisha. Atrocities against women, violence, poverty, corruption, the mediocrity of school and college education… the listless and tired souls all around and much more...

Art and culture seem to be alien in such a world, the existence of an intellectual showbiz and even a mafia not withstanding …the situation seems grim but the eternal optimist that I am… despite a million thrashings at the hands of life …. I believe that the future of humanity and culture still is bright and there is so much of happiness and good cheer… one only has to live and receive it with open arms… 

I salute all the upright, brave and modern day martyrs- men and women alike- who have had the courage to live by their convictions and have even laid their lives to a cause while most of the educated breed is only worried about making more and more money and be slaves to their careers… not that it is wrong…. But when one has no time for the happenings in ones immediate surroundings and one is not pro active to execute even the smallest of our duties as a citizen of the country, it worries me… of course most of us are involved in heavy intellectual discussions in elite drawing rooms over drinks and good food… maybe after all I am biased and we are indeed discharging our duty of being responsible citizens.

Today’s post is to celebrate a brave soul who has enriched me immensely during the course of my association with her. An abandoned woman who has fought the disease of alcoholism that her husband suffered for many years... and being very little educated, struggles to make a living to sustain herself. Today she has registered a small flat which she has bought in the middle of nowhere; for that is what her savings fetched her… The gold that her late father gave her at the wedding paid for it…. Maybe, dowry is not a bad idea after all… as for the years of service to the family she was married into, she had received no salary, no gratuity or insurance or provident fund and she found herself on the street without even an alimony, when she fell out of favor with the alcoholic husband…

My friend and senior writer, who is a British citizen of Indian origin laments the state of our country and its ruling elite even as his book on the martyrs of the independence of our country is published. In fact, I have come to admire his crisp, no nonsense writing which provokes me to introspect and reflect. Dr Reginald Massey (FRSA) is a writer I love to have severe intellectual differences with and below is the cover of his new book. Every word he says has a ring of reality and truth but I cannot digest his verdict. An acquaintance, who is an Indian of British origin pronounces that he has great faith in the country’s young and that they would be the saviors of the country. Even that, I find hard to believe…. watching the young and also my age group ( mid forties) which has nurtured these young. 



Do not the young learn when you live by principles and set an example for them? What example have we set for them? Of being practical, worldly wise, compromising on every value in the name of diplomacy and business acumen? We also have had the sagacity of sugar coating every digression we have made in the name of the system which compels us to do what we do; and against which one cannot hope to survive. 

Honesty today is rated on a relative grading scale. Once a senior government official in Kanpur was being talked about reverently as being very honest; his ticket to glory was that, once he took money he got the work done, come what may !!

A friend sent me a song by Paul Anka, a lovely number which spoke and reminisced of his father affectionately. Being a little down under due to over work, it was relaxing catching up with some music and poetry. I could not help but remember my “middle class” father, a modest scientist with the Defence Research and Development Organisation, who brought up his three children in a very modest, simple yet secure fashion. 

He was the most “unworldly wise” man I had ever seen and he called me one, when I grew up. We both lived by our hearts doing what made us happy oblivious to parameters of success. He never realized that may be, he had passed on this personality flaw to me through genetic make-up or just by setting an example. Dreaming big was not in his “dictionary”… a trait of a failure?

Art and culture was a part of growing up… but he could not afford to take us even by bus to the happening places in Delhi to watch cultural programs. He had the additional responsibility of a younger brother and sister too, for a long time, which drained out his finances. He did the next best thing; became the secretary of the Andhra Association and we tagged along with him watching dance and theatre. I do not even remember whom I watched but all I remember is that every activity and performance that I had watched was a joyful and beautiful experience. 

How big or popular the artist was; was not important…the experience was.

Another way of being connected to art and culture that my father invented was; to be a part of a local amateur theatre group and again, hanging around him, we children absorbed and enjoyed a lot. In no time we had our own group writing plays and enacting them only for ourselves…. We did not even need an audience… We painted to our heart’s content, wrote scripts, composed dance and once in a blue moon had the luxury of treating ourselves to a Samosa and Coca Cola.

No big arangetrams, or private classes or being sent to special classes in dance and music in chauffeur driven cars…. The teachers who came to teach dance and music at the Andhra Association changed frequently like the seasons; teaching a bunch of middle class children for modest fees could not be called lucrative….

Our reading appetites had to be fulfilled by the local lending library for which one had to save 25 paise per week...clothes we wore were modest and often stitched by mother; and again, hanging around her while she stitched, one got an opportunity to feel fabrics and think about design and fashion in one’s own small way.

“Sankoch” – a dash of reticence and shy demeanor was considered to be a weakness then; today maybe such a quality should be rated at a premium. For me, being harsh/ sarcastic with words and even being very vocal is a sign of aggression of which I am guilty of at times. Sharing emotions and a part of one’s life with people around was such a support system then; but today a part of being sophisticated and elite is living in your own ivory tower, lonely and even abandoned; no matter how successful you are …. 

What is the measure of happiness? Maybe greater achievements… professionally… or making more money…. The churning goes on…

What about ones conduct in day to day life? How many issues around us are ignored as we do not have the time to interfere, even though the matters tug at our civic/moral sense? We are busy professionals, artistes, writers. It is the government and the administration which has to take care of everything. One will not oppose a corrupt official or a goon for the fear of harassment or simply for the fear of wasting time.

Our driver quietly gave the official in charge of issuing death certificates, some money to expedite the process of obtaining my father’s death certificate. He felt that in the traumatic state of having lost my father recently I should not face the harassment of the application not coming through quickly.... He was trying to protect me; knowing my infamous persona of being a stubborn stickler for rules and having got into trouble often with many; including an errant builder, a road rage aggressor, government departments where I had to invoke the RTI to get to the base of the problem, etc. He has patiently driven me to a variety of these offices and has borne my emotional outbursts of exasperation and helplessness often when I had arrived at a dead end; and it was clear to me that my efforts cannot change the so called “system”, after all. I am a "common man" who can never dream to wield the power which could make a difference !!

The result is that my driver, my friends and my girls always worry for my safety; but I have not missed to notice that the girls have imbibed a streak of being upright with their morals and conscience. I am not an achiever or a "success" in any popular sense of the word. But yes, I feel no less successful than any of the so called “successful” celebrities. I take great pride and solace in the knowledge that I work very hard in my profession, do my best to be on the right side of my conscience and enjoy every person and every small bit of happiness that comes my way; I share my life unabashedly with all around me… and I still dare to trust and take every one at face value… 

I, for sure, am not a mal nourished soul.

Tuesday, 26 February 2013

Killing the Spectator


I reached Ravindra Bharati, the cultural hub of Hyderabad, to witness a Kuchipudi recital, dot at 6 pm, the appointed time of commencement of the performance. The program finally began at 7.20 pm with a book release function clubbed to the dance event; and the dance recital finally began at 8.15 pm. That was not just stretching the patience of the spectator a bit too far but instead; was a definitive attempt to kill the spectator. Then the organizers wonder why the classical programs attract so very few people; not to talk of the largess of mediocrity doled out in dance.

Bharata used the term prekshaka for a spectator. Abhinavagupta, the major commentator on Natyasastra used the term sahrdaya, for a sensitive spectator. Rasika (one who relishes aesthetic pleasure) is a term which emerges from the Srimad Bhagavata.  There are many such parallel terms for a spectator. The sacred and secular in art gave different terms to the spectator (also called the nagarika) - rasika (urban pleasure seeking elite) or the bhakta (devotee).

 Bharata says that the cultured people (sumanaska-s- who are of good heart and mind) make superior spectators.

Indeed, one has be very cultured not to lose one’s cool at the event management horrors and substandard performances. 

However the book release was enriching as was the dance by Mutnuri Yagnanarayana Sarma. The long sabha karyakramam gave me an interesting insight into the mind of the author, “Nagna muni" (a nom de plume) and his work, “Akasadevara” which was praised by some of the renowned critics present. The book is a comment on the phenomenon of “Marketing” of faith. The business of religion, faith and culture has assumed gigantic proportions with the commoditisation, politicisation and bureaucratisation of the same. The scams, the fanaticism and the exploitation in the name of religion and culture have assumed serious proportions with the media emerging as the hydra headed chimera aiding the phenomenon. The sale of astrological aids to good life, success, wealth and fame, religious discourses, etc. make great financial and TRP prospects. The governments do not touch influential business or religious groups as a part of their vote bank politics.

Culture today, especially dance is definitely suffering from bureaucratisation in the hands of the government and their bodies assigned to look after the propagation and preservation of the same. Whether one likes to use the term marketing, in connection with dance or not; dance has definitely been packaged and commoditised. It has to be made into a good selling proposition; at least to get grants from the relevant bodies.

Interestingly the huge ugly banner, the back drop in yesterday's performance gave the dancer's particulars as " Mutnuri Yagna- Of "Swathi Muthyam" cine fame..... The dancer could not help but draw on the filmi connection to give credibility to his stature; its another matter that he is such a good dancer that his art does not require any recommendation or endorsement.

Coming back to where I began; what about the poor spectator? 

Notwithstanding the tall order of qualities of a good dancer and a good production in the Natyasastra; no matter, how Bharata had envisaged the ideal dance/drama and the ideal dancer/actor; I intend to only look at the ideal spectator as defined by him, in this post.

One is free to draw one’s own conclusions on the rarity of the breed of spectators of classical dance. Even if one aspires to be an ideal one, the spectator could be killed by a combination of factors including mediocrity of the dance itself …. A dear friend who recently responded to my questionnaire for a project on Arts Marketing as a part of my Senior Research Fellowship of Ministry of Culture said, “The most disconcerting aspect of today’s dance scenario is that the artist/organiser no longer cares for the spectator.” 

Abhinavagupta in Abhinavabharati, has placed a great responsibility on the spectator....  a spectator ought to be a social being who is also so large hearted that he empathises with every individual of the society and thus is equipped to respond to the poet’s mind and thus can get immersed in the characters of the play and thereafter according to his samskara (culture, taste, sensibility) interpret the same.  

A spectator ought not be an analyser or moralist. Scholars and learned men have said that- " he cannot be built by education; instead he is supposed to be a  product of the refinement attained by complete submission and submersion in art.... just like the rocks which attain fine lustrous smoothness as they are constantly washed down by the river." Thus, becoming an ideal spectator is an arduous  and continuous process.

Art, in the Indian tradition is not for mere entertainment or is not just ornamental; it is considered to be sacred and moreover the spectator is not supposed to be a person of superficial disposition; he is expected to apply himself seriously and deliberately to enjoy and understand art. Natyasastra specifies in Chapter 27, verses 54-62 the qualities of a spectator... Bharata differentiates a critic (which I shall expound in some other post) from a spectator (prekshaka).

A person who is undisturbed, clean, imaginative, sympathetic and  unbiased is qualified to be called a prekshaka. He who vibrates sympathetically to joy or sorrow, anger and fear is a superior spectator. Bharata calls cultured people as sumanaska-s (of good heart and mind) who make superior spectators.

Bharata further says that the ideal spectator is one who is possessed of a good character, high birth, quiet behaviour, and learning, and is desirous of fame and virtue, impartial, advanced in age, proficient in drama in all its 6 aspects, alert, honest, unaffected by passion, expert in playing the 4 kinds of musical instruments, acquainted with costumes, and make up, the rules of the dialects, the four kinds of histrionic representation, grammar, prosody, and various other sastras, is very virtuous, expert in different arts and crafts and has the fine sense of the rasa- s (sentiments) and bhava-s (states)......

To be an ideal spectator is a pursuit of a lifetime and beyond.
But, is the spectator being provided with the art on which he can thrive ?



References:

Ghosh Manomohan, The Natyasastra, The Royal Asiatic Society of Bengal, Calcutta, 1950.
Dehejia Harsh V., The Advaita Of Art, Motilal Banarsidass Publ., 1996.