Saturday, 10 October 2015

Jugaad and Intolerance in Arts

Please go to page number 7 on the following link

http://nartanam.in/wp-content/uploads/2015/10/nartanam-vol-xv-no-2.pdf

Sunday, 20 September 2015

An Indian Analysis of Aesthetics- The Dance, the Dancer and the Spectator


Here is a peep into my first ever book.


What is it that makes a dance beautiful and what is the mechanism of reacting to dance in a spectator? Where does the onus for relishing aesthetic pleasure lie and how does it come about? These are the questions, which receive attention in my book.
Some of the best known critical-aesthetic thoughts and theories right from the ancient Greco-Roman philosophers such as Socrates, Plato, Aristotle, Cicero, Longinus, and Augustine, the ancient Indian aestheticians like Bharata, Anandavardhana, and Abhinavagupta to the much later Japanese aesthetician Zeami, and the later European theorists like Kant and Brecht, are discussed in the book and it is pointed out that they all speak of an element of the metaphysical in art.
Indian Dance and Music in the traditional classical format are ingrained in the psyche of every Indian as 'divine'. This nature of dance encompassed the myriad aesthetic theories on the existence of beauty in art, its universal nature and its portrayal that lead the spectator to experience the sublime. The ‘divine origin’ theory of Bharata in the Natyasastrawas propounded as a proof of the divinity inherent in dance. The excessive usage of pious vocabulary with reference to dance by one and all, its metaphysical content and the realisation of bliss as a spectator of dance is not uncommon. The primary Indian aesthetic theory ‘Rasa Sutra’ does not offer any explanation as to how the ‘aesthetic relish’ experienced is next only to the supreme divine bliss, brahmananda. It is also limited in the explication of the process/mechanism of its attainment in the spectator. While it applied to the poet, choreographer and the dancer and the process of production of the theatrical spectacle, the enumeration of the process of the reception of the beauty of the performance and attainment of aesthetic relish by the spectator did not receive much attention.
However, Abhinavagupta in his commentary on Natyasastra, the Abhinavabharati, does offer some insight into the subject. What is it that the spectator undergoes or ought to undergo in attaining the aesthetic relish? Can such aesthetic relish ever be equivalent to the supreme divine bliss of brahmananda, if at all such an experience is definable and is a possibility?
K. VasudevaSastri’s book on SangitaDarpanam, a 17th century treatise on music and dance, in an appealing section—sariraviveka—in its very first chapter, and the SangitaRatnakara  both describe a subtle metaphysical apparatus in the human body in the context of perception of dance and music. This, I think constitutes a theory or mechanism of spectatorship. Sariravivekaboldly proposes the presence of a metaphysical apparatus in the human body consisting of a primordial energy and an assortment of energy centres, which together appear to be an instrument for perceiving the essence of music and dance. This section of SangitaDarpanamaddresses the theory of spectatorship and thus contributes to the historiography of spectatorship.
Sahaja Yoga, a form of meditation propounded by Dr. NirmalaSrivastava, known to her followers as ShriMatajiNirmala Devi, has a vast body of research in medicine on the apparatus similar to the one described in the section sariraviveka in the treatise SangitaDarpanam.The subtle body similar to the one described by sariraviveka in SangitaDarpanam has been amply elaborated by the late U.C. Rai, an eminent physiologist of India in his book “Medical Science Enlightened —New Insights into Vibratory Awareness for Holistic Health Care” is of significance here.  He has explained the working of the metaphysical apparatus in the body and has supported it with research on Sahaja Yoga. Rai’s findings are collated with the apparatus described in the sariraviveka.
The book tries to examine the philosophy wherein the fine art over the ages has been propounded to have a ‘metaphysical’ aspect. An examination of various theories is to suggest that the age-old primary aim of the artistic process is not a mere expression of the self, as is popularly asserted by artists today. It is about relating the artistic process to self and striving for the elevation of the self by both the artist and the spectator. Fine art and its aesthetics have ever been intimately connected  with beauty, morals, ethics, spiritual uplift, education, and daily living. It was not seen merely as a skill or a knowledge intensive entertainment tool that happens to portray higher values and morals or merely as a tool of ritual in its religious context; its core purpose was always the discovery of self through the perception of universal truths.
The book stresses that an aesthetic theory ought not to focus only on the nature of art and its basic and formal principles but should also address the mechanism of the perception of beauty or the attainment of ‘aesthetic relish’ by the spectator.
It is generally argued that one cannot understand the classical arts without being thoroughly educated in the several forms and genres and acquiring a good knowledge of the fundamentals of aesthetics. Without being thus equipped, it is claimed that one cannot know what to look for in the high art of any ‘Great Tradition’. The book accepts this argument in the case of a scholar, teacher, performer and writer of art, but declares it incorrect in the case of a spectator.The book argues that one can lucidly perceive the arts even with a minimum of empathy and open-mindedness to one’s culture and with only a little knowledge about artistic pursuits. The indirect, implicit, and the universal in the arts portrayed successfully can be perceived, appreciated and even understood by the most ordinary of viewers through the innate subtle mechanism with which humans are equipped. This is the thrust of thought contained in the concept of sariraviveka. Thus this book proposes that the most highly encoded art can be perceived and appreciated by the most ordinary of viewers through an innate mechanism that all humans are equipped with.
The book also examines the various classical dance forms of India and dwells on the salient elements in their form, technique, and repertoire and also the content that contributes significantly to the important dimension of the experience of ‘the sublime’ through the art form.


Writer's Block



In the past few months I have contemplated withdrawing from writing on dance and also withdrawing from editing the journal Nartanam not because of financial hardships but because of :

lack of good academic writers,
lack of professionalism in the field,
lack of courage and conviction in one and all to raise issues haunting the dance field.

But as the publisher of Nartanam, and as a believer of the need for a journal like Nartanam I cannot help but continue with the crusade of publishing Nartanam every quarter- one bumper issue after the other, all in time and to great appreciation from one and all. The joy of compiling the content is as immense as is the pain and tears behind putting it together.

Amidst all the efforts at Nartanam, the  desire to update my blog took a back seat. But I am delighted that my blog is read by many like minded people.

I give here links to my editorials in Nartanam which was pretty much what I wanted to say in the past few months. One may check out page number seven in each of following links or on www.nartanam.in

http://nartanam.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/04/special-issue-on-spic-macay.pdf
http://nartanam.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/07/60-years-of-jawaharlal-nehru-manipur-dance-academy-imphal.pdf
http://nartanam.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/special-issue-on-dance-criticism-and-photography.pdf

http://nartanam.in/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/nartanam-vol-xiv-4.pdf

http://nartanam.in/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/nartanam-issue-jan-march-2015.pdf

http://nartanam.in/wp-content/uploads/2015/07/nartanam-issue-apr-jun-2015.pdf

Having said all that, the latest issue of Nartanam with a brand new editorial is in the press  and will be out in a  fortnight!

Tuesday, 20 January 2015

Parachuting Into positions of Power

Joined the party 5 days ago and she is the Chief Minister candidate of BJP in Delhi.

Kudos to the top bureaucrat, super cop in her day, for all her past achievements. Parachuting into a position of power/responsibility into the BJP top-cadre, her argument that the decision to "join politics" (which she so vehemently stayed away from) was a mystery to her, sounds, at the least, bizarre. Fighting for eradicating corruption and bringing about the Jan Lokpal just over a year ago as an activist, vowing to remain a neutral voice and never enter politics, she finds BJP and Modi highly deserving of her sycophantic praise. Fair enough! She is entitled to her opinion.

Politics is not my forte. 

What strikes me is that a team is built from grass roots and so does the leader grow through the ideology and working through the group. Yes, he could be a CEO recruited and foisted from outside but an essential fact is that he has to take his time and work his way to be a team member and a leader.

Politics are plenty in dance. Dancers, dance administrators and everybody of their ilk are constantly trying to parachute into some place of importance or the other.  Strangely none of them achieve anything in the larger interest of dance while they hold positions of so-called power.  While in position they remain in coteries and ivory towers never scouting and building able teams to assist them and operate in the same rut in which the organisations have been mired in for ages. And when the honeymoon is over, they lament the system and corruption, for not being able to do anything constructive. If only, those who hold offices of some significance are bold leaders. 


The term "dance" could be very well read as "arts" in this outburst.

On the other hand, if only the dancers could devote an iota of their efforts for a common cause instead of sitting on the fence, when it comes to speaking up for issues and acting for their own cause, dance would not have been a poor cousin to many other departments in the corridors of power. 

Leadership is not about one man. Its about the important players coming together having a conviction, a goal and the wherewithal to work after understanding what one is best at and contribute ones best towards the cause, rising fearlessly above personal ambitions.  Be it a party or an institute or a corporate organisation, its all about team work and common goals while having individual career paths. 

And... no short cuts....  no instant gratification ... no parachuting into plum positions ... will salvage the pathetic place that arts occupy in our national agenda....

Tuesday, 28 January 2014

For "Senior Officers" ONLY

The "common man" has created quite a flutter in Delhi with the Aam Aadmi party catapulting to power. Even as Arvind Kejriwal is ripped apart into pieces by the Indian media one cannot but see the crystal clear thinking of the man; and the bane that the issues raked up by Kejriwal are. The Indian media appears either to be on the rolls of some or the other political party, or to be too dumb to qualify for a responsible and intelligent media. When I say this, I also concede that there are exceptions to the case. While the media and the experts judge Kejriwal by the day; and pooh pooh his angst as much ado about nothing; today, I was witness to the sentiment which is building up and boiling over; and sooner or later the slightest trigger will herald a revolution. After all, the fruits of freedom we enjoy today are because; more than a century ago a barrister was thrown out of a first class railway compartment in South Africa.

Today, at the office of the Joint Commissioner of Police- Hyderabad I saw that there were two elevators to take people up and down the mere five floors of the building. One of the elevators had a sign above it- "Only for Senior Officers" and the sign on the other elevator read, "For Junior officers and others". The senior officers' elevator had a policeman posted in front of it to see to that no one else boarded the elevator; and when an exalted official boards the elevator, the guard on duty would spare the officer of the drudgery of pressing the relevant button to take him to his destination floor. An old man who had to wait for a long time for his turn to get into the overworked and overcrowded,  "Junior officers and others" elevator, commented that class and caste can never be banished from the Indian psyche. The signs reeked of the stench of the typical Indian babudom where an officer of higher rank exists in a rarefied atmosphere; and thus cannot travel in the same lift with his juniors !!! leave alone with outsiders and common public.

This babudom seems to be the hallmark of all fields in India. Look at the haughty countenance of a Member of Parliament or a Member of Legislative assembly or a bureaucrat; and a picture of royalty flashes in front of one's eyes. A dash of arrogance, the discourtesy in talking or the aloof air in communicating or their outright rudeness makes one wonder about the training of these politicians and officers; and above all their pious intention of serving the people. Again, I will have to concede that there are exceptions who baffle by their utmost humility. 


 In the capital city of my country, one often sees the bureaucrats in charge of cultural bodies being idolised as the Maharajas or even as Gods by artists; as they are the ones who dole out largess at their whim and fancy; often oblivious of today's concerns of art and culture and the vision or the mandate of the bodies they run. 

There is a hierarchy other than that of a guru  and sishya (the teacher and the student) in dance and other arts. The  high and mighty in arts are distinguished not often by their superlative art  but by how well connected they are or how many boards or committees they grace as members/advisors and the awards they are decorated with. They are the royalty of arts! Or are they the babudom of arts? Is arts untouched by the syndrome of " Senior Officers only"?





Friday, 1 November 2013

ETTIQUETTE- Academic or otherwise


A senior scholar objecting to the word “prostitute” used in the context of devadasis in a book review by another scholar in Nartanam shot off a letter to the editor.  In it, he does not mince words about the moral fiber of the dancers today and the levels they can stoop to, for garnering awards and other benefits from the powers that be. He thus justifies that the term “prostitute” would be as applicable to dancers today (He was talking in the Indian context.) as it was to the devadasis, then.

However, citing the degradation of the ethical grain of dancers today, does not negate the fact that the socio-economic and other factors did lead to the exploitation of many of the devadasis, if not all, which compelled them into prostitution, which might not have been by choice.  And when a devadasi was in a live-in relationship with a man of her choice (to whom she might have been more faithful than a wife); it was because she was already married to God as per the oppressive ritual order of devadasis; and hence was not allowed to marry a mortal. Asserting the fact that many of the devadasis were pushed into prostitution, especially when arts patronage under the temple and royalty saw a downward slide, does not cast a slur on them or their exemplary art. It is a mere comment on the sorry state of the society at that point of time, and even as recently as in the mid 20th century.

An army friend related instances when he chanced meeting a couple of Indian dance divas on different occasions; and he did not bother to be subtle in expressing his reservations about the overtly evocative behaviour of the dancers, off stage. Of course, one cannot brand every dancer by the same yardstick and any such generalization would be blasphemy. Moreover, no one is entitled to take up the role of a morals/values commentator/judge. Well, all that is beside the point and I come back to academics.

All I want to put forth is that wielding the right to freedom of expression comes with a lot of responsibility. This is especially so in case of a community which deals with the most refined derivative of human mind and spirit- artists/scholars. The grace of written/spoken word and manner is imperative for artists and academicians.

Classical art is replete with suggestion, poise and exploring the transcendental. The personal state of mind/emotion of a dancer or actor is irrelevant when he/she is performing.  So is the case in academics of classical arts or any other subject. While putting forth an academic argument there is no scope for being personal or getting emotional.   It would then be no different from a vicious skirmish. And moreover, a scholar could be guilty of a researcher’s bias when he is  emotionally high-strung about his argument.

At this, I cannot help but recollect a dear friend’s writing style which is laced with a poetic tone even when he forcefully makes his point to the extent of being nasty!

No, I am not advocating a licence to be poetically vicious!





Friday, 20 September 2013

Egoism and Insanity in Classical Dance

When in Delhi, I am ensconced at the Sangeet Natak Akademi library, a pleasant place with lovely staff and above all a good collection of books and journals. I do not venture to watch much of dance in the evenings as I have to negotiate a great distance back to where I stay in NOIDA by the metro rail. The city makes me feel jittery after sunset. The crudity of the Delhi "lehza" is harsh on my sensibilities and does not generate much confidence in the humanity of the place. Its tough to trust an autorickshaw ride or a cycle rickshaw journey back home from the nearest metro station. The vast lonely stretches of roads makes one very uncomfortable at night.

My friend nudged me to catch up the Bharatanatyam recital of a talented dancer, Lakshman, and I succumbed to the temptation. Of the many concerns the classical dance presentations arouse in me.... all of which I shall not expound here.... I have to report the following.

Lakshman is technically excellent; but has put on weight and has become sluggish on his feet.... abhinaya is not his forte but he had to present a varnam to prove his mettle.... so far so good...

Sudha Raghuraman, a singer par excellence was accompanying on the vocals.... its not her fault that she is a fantastic singer.... but the singer forgets that she is an accompaniment and the beautiful and yet unnecessary flourishes in singing, which are not being executed in dance movement, are a distraction. They take away the spectator from the dancer and the dance. Why is the simple fact that dance is the visual execution of the lyric and music forgotten and the singer charts a course of her own while the dancer is not able to execute the same? In this case even the mridanga player sought to highlight his instrument by demanding an increase in the volume of his mike.

What is the point? I go to watch a Bharatanatyam recital.... and end up getting snatches of excellent singing and spirited playing of the mridnga.... a bit of dancing here and there only when the dancer manages to overshadow the parallel performances of the accompanists... the egoistic components of what could have been a fine product.... if only they see sanity.....and care for their art; if not for the supreme sacrifice of the spectator.... who braves difficult logistics to come and watch the program.

The role of accompanists needs to be examined with urgency. Sense must prevail to prevent the already "out of context" presentations of classical dances from becoming caricatures....

I pray to God that I am blessed with the ability to enjoy whatever comes my way and be sympathetic and tolerant in my report/review of the performance and .....enjoy my martyrdom as a spectator at the altar of insane presentation of the classical dances of my country.

Wednesday, 14 August 2013

Woman–Independence- Arts/ Business and Nartanam


That is quite a confusing assortment of issues in one title.

Maybe reading on will present clarity.

“But that is UNFAIR to a man,”said my nephew in a conversation which veered around women’s rights and a famous divorce wherein the man had to part with a handsome portion of his life’s savings to his wife who made his home while he earned the big bucks.

“Mother, you are in danger of sounding extinct!” - reacted my daughter a few years ago,  to my sage advice as she was leaving for the USA for her under graduation. All I had suggested was that it was in the woman’s nature to nurture and be the pivot of a family and that it may be worth its while to consider the same when she sets out to make a career and a life.

“You are too radical in your thoughts!” say my men friends when I suggest that women’s unpaid work at home is an important force behind the paid work that men undertake; and when assessed, it could turn out to be a substantial slice of the economy and the GDP of any country.  

The efforts of women as home makers, care givers, tutors to their children, caring for their elderly, being around the family as a support system in many small and big ways goes unacknowledged. It is another matter that most women home makers find their unpaid job to be extremely rewarding, emotionally.  

Arguments in favor of women’s unpaid work are either cold shouldered or met with indulgent smirks; or worse, a judgement is passed that the arguing woman is not a lady of culture. Of course, there is no dearth of elite drawing room- arm chair high thinking in my country which is not a penny’s worth. 

Women and independence at times seem to be mutually exclusive terms. The feminists would love seeing me barbecued on hot coals for saying that.

Moving on to Arts/ Business and Nartanam, a journal of dances of India:

“Mother, you sound too meek; a go get-er has to be aggressively articulate,” said my daughter who is studying law, when I commented that the spokespersons of various political parties are too aggressive in their voluminous sound bytes on Television and seem to be so devoid of etiquette/culture.

“Your children are grown up; what stops you now? You are too regressive to be a successful career woman,” said a well meaning successful friend when I cited family as a reason for refusing to locate to Delhi for better work opportunities.

“You have to make the journal financially viable. You cannot finance it from your pocket drawing from your husband’s resources!”-  said a well meaning aunt. I have barely taken over the sick journal from its former publishers for whom I had worked gratis for a long time. My artistic inclination and work were highly appreciated; as long as it did not demand investment of money. That a venture needs some seed capital and a gestation period before it breaks even; more so a financially sick journal dealing with classical arts, is a negligible fact.

“But you cannot close down such a fantastic journal! We are with you,” say well meaning friends from the field. One is grateful for their moral support.

“Can we purchase the latest issue of Nartanam? We do not want to take a subscription,” said a caller. When asked why he wants this latest issue, he informs that his daughter is a dancer and her picture is there on one of the pages.

Dancers do not have time to read. Yes, they sure are interested to be on the pages of the journal. Dance students cannot be accused of having had a brush with serious reading on dance; they have never had the fortune of seeing their seniors or teachers at it.

However, most of our readers are genuine lovers of dance; not the dancers or dance students. The latest is a doctor from USA who was so touched by the wealth of Indian dance presented in Nartanam’s pages that he wants to buy all the past issues and donate it to a temple library in the USA so that its contents are seen by many others.

It is impossible to deal with government libraries. They all want the books but payments are harassing slow.  Government orders of our special issues are too risky to execute. If the concerned IAS official is transferred; ones supplies are stuck up and usually the succeeding IAS officer likes to reverse everything the former was up to. 

“But what happens to my own writing?” I protest. Reviving the journal has taken me away from my own writing. I am caught up with Nartanam’s financial viability while also ensuring the publication of a world class issue every three months.

Sublime Arts and literature had always flourished under the royal and elite patronage or were the fruits of passion of maverick saints and artists. Has one ever heard of traders taking up elite arts as profitable business ventures?

I am no royalty and one cannot mistake me for a saint or artist. Yes, I do seem to be a maverick to have taken up the sick journal; and continue bringing out a dazzling issue, dot on time every quarter; and yes, I seem to have no option but to run Nartanam on a business model.

That, my friends, is the story of Nartanam which at the moment needs subscribers, advertisers and may be a patron or two (if not royalty) who believe in its work and are willing to finance it at this difficult juncture.

Nartanam’s work and worth is there for everyone to assess at www.nartanam.in and you are free to contact me at editornartanam@gmail.com


Sunday, 4 August 2013

“Is your mother a Member of Parliament?”

Foreword: This piece is a salute to the best of systems in my country which continue to render their best despite a million constraints and obstacles;  and do so with the dignity of an indefatigable spirit.

“Is your mother a Member of Parliament?”

I was quite taken aback by the rather innocuous inquiry at the Central Government Health Scheme (CGHS) counter at the Nizams Institute of Medical Sciences (NIMS) in Hyderabad. The person who asked the question was the rather affable and endearing clerk, processing the admission of my mother into the private ward of the hospital for a major surgery for stomach cancer.

“Why do you ask?” I said.
“This is the most expensive ward, occupied only by VIPs”, he said.

It was then that I realized: my late father, who was a man of very humble means till his last breath, (his father incidentally was a doctor, an FRCS from London who served the last Nizam of Hyderabad), did attain a significant position in his government job; which entitled his surviving spouse to avail the facility of a decent room and world class treatment in a government hospital. 

A five star cancer hospital which my mother chose at first for its great ambiance and infrastructure (which had generated great confidence in her), hesitated to operate upon her due to the high risks involved in the surgery (read it as …. possible absence of a wide variety of experts in house, to treat complicated cases). However, the surgeons of the government hospital exhibited great confidence and sagacity in planning the surgery; considering carefully, all the risks involved. 

A month long association with the NIMS and watching the things around me; I write this piece even as my mother is in the Surgical Intensive Care Unit (which looks like a dingy rickety medical facility from medieval times). One even wonders, if anybody has ever emerged alive from it. The pre- operation surgical ward would have even the bravest, running away from the surgery at the last minute… But if the facility is good enough for my countrymen who flock to the hospital in large numbers… then definitely it should be good enough for me or my mother or even a VIP or even the Prime Minister of the country.

One might wonder what is the point I am driving at and who has compelled me to get my mother treated at the hospital whose facilities seem so bleak and moreover,

 What does culture have to do with this saga?

I went to NIMS; only for advice from the surgical oncology and surgical gastroenterology departments, which was mandatory; so that my mother could avail the government funding to get treated at a hospital of her choice (a five star facility near my home). 

I waited in the endless Qs of the sea of humanity at NIMS to meet the doctors in their ramshackle office (Some of their departments are now housed in brand new state of art buildings with plush interiors, but not the surgical gastroenterology department and the operation theaters.)

At the first meeting with the doctors I could not help but feel- Why can they not smile a tad more to make the patient comfortable? ( I have got used to an overdose of hospitality and PR skills travelling round the country as the representative of  a premier journal on dance, Nartanam and also having exposure to the  PR and HRD functions of the corporate sector by virtue of my education in Business Management.) 

But, here are the reasons why my mother and I chose the government facility over any other:

The tehzeeb of the doctors came through in the calm and yet the reassuring way they talked, minus any attitude and show off....

The senior most anesthetist, whom the surgeons wanted to handle my mother’s complicated case, looked positively unapproachable and his menacing steady gaze at the first sight did not seem very warm; and I could not but help wish again that the doctors smiled more often to let the patient know that the doctor is not a monster whom you have to bear with, to get treated. Is medicine with its human element and compassion not a subtle art in itself with its own aesthetic?

However, the calm and composed mannerism of the senior most anesthetist, as I observed him a couple of times more, had me wanting to believe in him. I could even appreciate the cultured personage behind a tad too spartan facade. I developed immense faith in him and in the affable head of the department of surgical gastroenterology and his able team - not just because of their professional credentials- but because of the stated elegance in their very presence.... which was  not misplaced; the way my mother's surgery was accomplished.

In arts, especially in dance, this very quality of calm or tranquility which translates into elegance as the dancer displays his/her skill is called Thehraav; which comes from the self assurance emerging from intensive training in the art form and a deep understanding of nature, culture and ones own SELF.

The huge NIMS  runs quite efficiently with the support staff working like cogs in a wheel catering to large volumes of the sick who are also poor. 

But yes, enhancing the infrastructure and attempting to provide a more humane touch by training the support staff to be a little courteous (Maybe just a smile and a gentle tone of speech would do) would multiply the capable doctors’ magnificent efforts. Having said that, I wonder if hospitals are not considered a hospitality sector?

Culture is definitely an essential ingredient of all professions. 
I certainly have discovered that culture is very much a part of the doctors I have come across at NIMS. Moreover, the manifestation of culture in a person need not always be on overt display or be loud or voluminous or stylish in words or deeds; culture could rest in the smallest of ones mannerisms.

And if the Director of NIMS cares for the feed back of an ordinary citizen; he could arrange for the training of the support staff to be courteous and efficient;
and do well to immediately get better infrastructure to do justice to the efforts of the world class doctors working at the institute.

HRD (Human Resource Development) in corporate style is not what I am hinting at! 

May be a deep conversation with the sterling arts-  especially music, dance, literature and the like- right from ones early growing years is the only way to enrich a person with exalted human values. 


On a lighter note, maybe NIMS should begin by immediately replacing the table seen below:
Note the ingeniously bandaged legs of the table- to keep it from collapsing.

Thursday, 18 July 2013

Deconstructing SELF WORTH


I want fame and power... money may follow
or
I want money... fame and power may follow.

I am not suggesting that quest for above is unethical in any way. 

I want to look beyond the self righteous, rational, and conscious mind of mine to know what actually motivates me at my work; and if there is a cut throat subconscious rationale which actually works stronger and guides my work. 

Whatever be the quality of my work and my contribution to the world at large, does not the above mantra  play a defining role in what I do and how I do it? Einstein, Edison, Shakespeare, Beethoven or Van Gogh- all who attained fame or success in their lifetime or after; what did they aspire for?

A love and commitment for what they were doing and a burning desire to satisfy their artistic or scientific quest seems to have lead to their contribution becoming so immense that they have been immortalized. If they had any faculties of financial acumen and if they had designed the graph of their success consciously, is a matter that I do not know of.

I know for sure that today, the need to be recognized and to wield influence (by being written about; by being seen in peer communities, on social medium and social circuits; by being on committees that matter in terms of prestige or which offer one the satisfaction of being considered as eminent and also offer the power to trade favors; or by being honored and awarded- no matter what the award or honor is), is quite pressing.

I cannot leave the matter of being influential to follow the excellence in my work but instead I have to work consciously towards attaining the desired position of influence.

Fame or recognition seems to invest me with a high sense of self worth. 
I justify aspiring for it; but I wonder why does not a good body of ones work, by itself, lead to the self worth, nullifying the need for recognition. A peer review or appraisal and approval is more important to evaluate and correct my work but not to enhance my self worth.


I shall not probe any further.... for I might discover my true intentions/ motivations... and the pious garb may unveil my reality....

Saturday, 15 June 2013

Maybe, we now need HR Consultants in Arts.

Last week I was with the founder publisher of Nartanam, who in recouping from a bad bout of spondylitis was glad that I dropped by to have lunch with him and thereafter spend time to visit the vibrant Kuchipudi scenario from his past. Despite a killing schedule of mine I could not take leave of him as he went down the memory lane of his association with Vempati Chinna Satyam. As was always the case, I ended up handing him tissues to wipe the streaming tears of affection and reverence for the great Master.

Watching the video recordings from the 80s and 90s of the Kuchipudi Mahotsavas conducted by the Kuchipudi Kala Kendra which brought together the entire Kuchipudi fraternity, brought many things to the mind.

G M Sarma, founder of  the once vibrant Kuchipudi Kala Kendra, Mumbai and the former publisher of Nartanam is past the prime of his robust organizing days. At the simplest, he can be termed as a Kuchipudi connoisseur minus any personal agenda; who did his selfless best for the propagation of Kuchipudi and retired gracefully.

Quite in contrast are today’s many managers/organizers of arts festivals who revel in the bloated perception of being the “karta dharta’ of arts and the artists. Especially the “want to be’s” have no option but to pander to the egos of these entities who wield considerable influence. 
               
As one watched the videos of the great maestro Vempati performing, one could not help but realize that here was a maestro who was capable of being a star performer himself. Flawless “saushtava” (the perfect body posture, line), the charming gait, the perfected ease of technique, the magnetic presence on stage; he was no doubt a scintillating performer material.

But he went on to attain fame as an excellent teacher and choreographer whose pantheon of stellar disciples is truly vast. An excellent leader and team player, his revolutionized Kuchipudi in a way only he could have. The best of writers, music composers, musicians, singers, make-up artists, his teaching assistants, patrons and disciples- all rallied around him and he held them with the awe that his art inspired in them. And thus, was created the best of art. None from the team sought individual stardom; they all rallied around the maestro to create his master pieces. They were happy with his art and the immense fame it garnered for him. Would terming them as “selfless” be too big a credit accorded to the team members who were not mere mortals in their own right.

Apart from the leadership that the Master and his art inspired, it was the lack of craving for individual fame and stardom which makes those team members unique. It is another matter that every one of the team members today is a legend in his/her own right- S. V. Bhujangaraya Sarma, an eloquent poet,           P. Sangeetha Rao, a fabulous musician, Parthan, the set designer, Kanaka Durga, the ethereal singer, Bala Kondala Rao, Master’s right hand in teaching and choreographing, his star dancers, whose list is endless; and I shall not even make an attempt to list them….

I cannot but draw comparison here to Sergei Diaghilev, the Russian impresario who revolutionized Ballet by the sheer magnificence of the team that he built. Every member was a gem of an artist who worked towards the team goal of  creating a flawless artistic product.

Recently, talking to Vedantam Venkatachalapati Rao, one of the most talented youngsters of Kuchipudi and reminiscing about his equally talented elder brother Vedantam Raghava, a dancer par excellence, especially in playing the flamboyant roles in the Kuchipudi Yakshaganas, who now lives in the USA; I could not help but complain that- not one such leader as Vempati Chinna Satyam has emerged in this generation while, individually, there are many talented dancers and teachers, who may attain fame. But none, I am sure, will be hailed for generations to come.

To even fathom, how on this God’s big complex earth was such a team put together by Guru Vempati Chinna Satyam, could be a great challenge for the best of the Human Resource Consultants.

Maybe, now Art will need Human Resource Consultants- to put together teams which will create great art.


Wednesday, 15 May 2013

Not a part of SPIC MACAY




To write my blog I am usually looking out for pleasant and inspiring happenings in day to day life which enable my pen to write in enthusiasm. But it is also interesting and at times amusing to observe the other side of human nature… cunning, aggression and mistrust which drains all energies and takes one away from productive work…

Not long ago I wrote a piece about Dr Kiran Seth and how an entire movement was spearheaded to a dizzy success just because the man is the bearer of an honest simplicity. Of course he could not have done it without the sterling volunteers who make his mission possible. My writing was from my first hand interaction with Kiran Seth and his gems of volunteers. 

In fact, my young daughter who read the post, “How does one figure out Kiran Seth” commented, “Ma, you have created a new God, adding one more to the already huge pantheon of Gods in India.”

All I could tell her was, you have to meet him to believe me.

Today I am inspired to write how a couple of other volunteers of the movement have amused me, frightened me, and have compelled me to reflect-  if aggression could ever be a justified means of attaining a goal, however worthy it might be.

A very small job of editing a souvenir for the 1st international convention of SPIC MACAY at IIM-C, Kolkata, gave me a first hand experience of chaos in communication, unclear duties and responsibilities, non cooperation, disrespect for a fellow human being, especially in mails, ego hassles and above all a rare cunning which  did not appear constructive.

I seek forgiveness if I sound judgemental, but I share this post as an exercise in reflecting how I can rise above petty human emotions to make my life better and thus make the world a better place to live in.

When I was bogged down, not knowing how to accomplish my work in a chaotic situation I was confronted with, I gave up and eased myself out of the project. But within no time I was again sought by the organizers to take up the task of creating the Souvenir. 

And much against commonsense, I put aside an important order which I had to execute to earn the much needed money for my journal on classical dances of India, Nartanam. Since the Souvenir had to be executed at the last minute, I had no other option but to utilize the designer and printing slots allotted for Nartanam at my regular press, delaying my own project . It is important to point out that the Souvenir was delayed by the trademark lack of clarity and mis- communication and even excessive communication in SPIC MACAY even though the content was ready. All the top writers whom I had sought were utmost professional and had sent in their beautiful pieces well before the deadline. Wasting precious human resource by doubling the work; and confusion with too many cooks spoiling the broth is another syndrome which was difficult to handle.

It is another matter that no one reads on classical arts any more; not realizing that the sastra or the theory is as important for an artist and a spectator as the actual performance is.

A couple of volunteers whom I sought help from did all that they could without batting an eyelid while some others were creating agony and confusion.  

One of the volunteers who lives in my city, whom I was not acquainted with earlier, was of great help. His excellent attitude and quick thinking ability was an asset. A meticulous worker with sharp skills, he was an editor’s delight. With his help, the entire souvenir took shape against many odds and has now gone for print; and hopefully it will reach Kolkata in time for the inauguration of the Convention.

Happy that the souvenir has been put to bed I left the press; and before getting on with my other pressing engagements checked my mail as a routine; and to my amusement, I find a mail that this volunteer (who was an asset with his attitude and skills and gave all help to a stranger like me and did all the menial jobs assigned to him, if at all any job can be called so....) is declared as not belonging to the city SPIC MACAY by the group leader due to some serious issues with him.

Can a volunteer be banished for a little or a great fault, if any at all? who decides who is at fault? Whatever be the reason, can cultural ambassadors be intolerant and unprofessional and thus aggressive?

As Bertrand Russell puts it- the vagaries of human nature!

It might take a lot of culture to overcome these vagaries!

Monday, 15 April 2013

A Judgement


Today’s blog comes from a friend’s verdict on me yesterday after a minor/maybe a major altercation with him over a trivial personal issue but unfortunately placed at  a time of the turbulent milieu of my high passion and severe frustration of running a classical dance journal Nartanam. A journal which is highly respected in dance and academic circles, but costs a handsome packet of money in publishing it every quarter of an year; which many want it almost free of cost or complementary. Paying for a subscription of thousand Indian rupees per annum is a terrible expense (discounted price is Rs 750 only, which one spends in one evening watching a movie…); that is not the issue under discussion…. It is that no dancer or dance student has the time to read. Reading on dance by a dancer (though sastra is an integral part of learning and viewing dance) is only when a newspaper carries a review of her/his performance or when Nartanam publishes an article with a picture of the dancer. Many have expressed that if dance is presented in the format of a film news magazine, maybe they would be interested in reading.



Back and Front page of the latest issue of Nartanam- A special on the great Kutiyattam exponent
Late Guru Mani Madhava Chakyar


 Coming back to the verdict of my dear friend; it was, “You have no sense of decorum. You have been really damaged by your past with many complexes….Therefore all your Yoga has not helped you.”

Indeed it has set me thinking.... if I am unable to maintain dignity and decorum in my day to day life and in my efforts to pursue my love; then it is no love at all… especially the love of classical arts…. 

One does not make public, one's troubled past which many of us have in one way or the other locked away…. barring a few who by virtue of a silver spoon of high birth or fortune may never have had a trouble in their entire lives. To be fair to the people in my life …. I shall maintain the anonymity of the alcoholic who is supposed to have damaged my past and induced in me, many complexes…. But I will not shy away from mentioning that I was indeed a severely battered family member of an alcoholic. An alcoholic who is now recovering and who has had the grace and dignity of setting a beautiful example of what grit and strength is, what forgiveness is all about. He has not only built back his own battered life but has assumed all his worldly responsibilities towards everyone he is related to… and even towards people he is not related to.

....and above all, ironically, this recovering alcoholic gives me the assurance when the going gets tough financially at the journal, that he is there to pick up the bills of Nartanam and actually does so every time I run short of funds.

I have often wondered why I do the work I do, write and publish a serious academic journal on Indian dance.  Having spent my youth juggling with the tough deal of cards that life dealt me; ending up completely wrecked and exhausted; where living every new day was an ordeal and was infested with great uncertainty… Did I get suddenly ambitious of becoming a culture vulture and thus schemed and designed my life to become a writer, teacher and publisher of a dance journal, a career which does not pay in India. No, I did not…. I just went about doing what circumstances had led me to, followed my passion and what I believed in.

Now I come to another part of my friend’s verdict …. Sahaja Yoga, a form of meditation. Practicing it gave me immense peace and serenity during my troubled times. It gave me the grace and dignity to deal with things, gave me the qualities of forgiveness, satisfaction, innocence, true seeking of knowledge, a diplomacy and sweetness of voice and approach and above all a sense of self realization. But yoga was soon forgotten as better times arrived and my  focus shifted from my miseries to the “Moha maya” of life and pursuits of worldly love and goals….

Nartanam is one such goal… what if we bring out a world class journal on classical arts? What if it is in a small way, an effort to preserve and propagate our culture? What if it requires the toil and labor demanding sweat and blood? What if it does not pay the writers and the people running it even for their bread? Generating the finances to run it without compromising on the quality of the content is in itself a huge task…. 

And the irony is that a recovering alcoholic… who was no better than the scum of the earth, not long ago, is its patron… He does not believe in supporting a non self sustaining venture…. but has the compassion and the hope  that the journal ought to be given a decent chance to survive…. especially after being taken over in a financially sick condition from the former publisher….

Many luminaries and successful people who are on the board of advisers of Nartanam are rendering their moral support by lending graciously their eminent and renowned names to the journal… there are writers (though very few) who send in excellent writings with no expectation of financial remuneration….God has been benevolent…. Somehow money comes to pay the printers and the writers. Then what is it that bothers me, troubles me, and leads me to behave in frustration while dealing with personal and professional issues, to warrant the comment…

“You have no sense of decorum. You have been really damaged by your past with many complexes….Therefore all your Yoga has not helped you.”

I do not know! But I want to figure out... as anything worth doing ought to be done with grace and dignity… or else it is better not done…there is no place for frustration and palming off my behavior to some relevant/irrelevant factor…. Sahaja Yoga was not to be used as a  mantra for negotiating problems … it was meant  to be a way of life… Her Holiness Shri Mataji  (Dr. Nirmala Srivastava) left behind a simple form of meditation which  has now been thoroughly subjected to scientific exploration  by eminent institutions for holistic health and it has been researched for its impact on aesthetics of a beautiful life and of arts. 

I have written an elaborate book on the spirituality, divinity, aesthetics and spectatorship of classical performing arts and have discovered a theory from a medieval treatise on dance which expounds a mechanism which has been coincidentally, adequately clarified and researched in Sahaja Yoga and the medical fraternity…. And I wanted to publish this book.  Please believe me, I do not have any religious prejudices and my approach to the above mentioned work was purely academic and scientific…

But after my friend’s judgement…. which, after the initial emotional outburst, I am examining clinically…Maybe,  I am neither a worthy author for expounding such profound beauty of classical arts and its theories; maybe I am not worthy of an exalted form of meditation like Sahaja Yoga, and further, maybe, I am not even a worthy editor of a much worthy journal which deals with divinity… with arts... with dance.

I can pray to the almighty to help me in my efforts to spiritually uplift myself which might reflect in every aspect of my personality in ordinary and extra ordinary circumstances of stress, in times of these worldly affairs and passions… .

If only, every person who values his country/ culture/ arts made an attempt to buy and read Nartanam which costs peanuts… I do not have to run from pillar to post seeking donations, advertisements and patronage and grants from government bodies and corporates alike…. 

Readership is the only patronage which can run Nartanam…. We, the people, shall contribute to keep our culture alive…. And then, any amount of toil, failures and frustrations would be worth it.

Strange is my post today which mixes up my personal passions, failings and a larger interest of a non profit venture. My miserable past, I cannot erase…. and will have to deal with the complexes arising from it... and hopefully somewhere I would attain the decorum to carry on with conviction in my beliefs without succumbing to stress and failures.